Vincenzo'sPlace South
The story

A neighborhood kitchen.

Started 2016. Same family. New neighborhood.

Vincenzo's opened in 2016 — a family pizza shop in York, PA, where customers became friends and friends became family. We hand-tossed every pie, cut our own fries, and made our sauce in-house. Same as we'd do at home.

About seven months ago we sold the York shop to spend more time with our daughter Mia — school pickups, dinners at six, all the normal things you miss while you're behind the counter. The break was good. The pizza-shaped hole in our hearts was real.

When the chance came to open a new shop right here in Fawn Grove — a place we'd actually looked at years ago, before the original Vincenzo's — it felt like the right kind of pull. Same family. Same recipes. Same Vincenzo's Place you grew to love. Just south.

Same people.
Same food.
Only South.
— The Vincenzo's Family · Fawn Grove, PA
Three rules

Why people come back.

Most of what we do isn't fancy. It's fresh, generous, and consistent. That's the whole secret.

01 Fresh, every day

Dough, sauce, hand-cut fries — made in-house, same day. We'd rather sell out at 8pm than serve you yesterday's batch. The lunch you eat at noon comes from a kitchen that's been moving since 10am.

02 BYOB, no funny stuff

No corkage games, no markup. Bring what you want, we'll uncork it. South County Brewery is six steps next door if you want craft.

03 Generous portions

A 16" Vincenzo's Special is a 16" Vincenzo's Special. Lunch combos feed you. Pasta dinners come with salad and bread. Nobody leaves hungry.

04 Same family, new neighborhood

Giuseppe, Mia, and a kitchen that's been hand-tossing since 2016. We're not a chain. We're not a concept. We're the pizza shop on Mill Street — and pretty soon we'll know what your kid orders.

A note

From the Family —

You know, I've heard it said before that "you make plans and God laughs." About 7 months ago, with sadness and heavy hearts, we sold our thriving pizza shop in York, PA. We loved it there, and our customers became our friends who eventually became what felt like our family. We thought that it was time for a change for our little family of 3 — taking Mia to school, picking her up, dinner together in the evening, and all the normal things we missed while running our pizza shop.

In the evenings, Giuseppe and I would look at each other, and while we were grateful for the time we were spending with Mia, we were feeling like some part of us was missing. Even Mia would comment that she missed the pizza shop!

Fast forward to a couple of weeks ago, when we got a phone call offering us another pizza shop — one that we were looking at before we even bought Vincenzo's Place all those years ago!

We thought we knew what we wanted, but He had other plans! And from experience we know that God's plans are always good — He's rarely early, but never late!

We are ready to shine His light and offer our best to Him and to our new neighbors down in Fawn Grove, PA!

It's the same people, same food, the same Vincenzo's Place you grew to love — only SOUTH!

We cannot wait to build new friendships and a sense of community at our new location!

Stay tuned — we can't wait to welcome you to VINCENZO'S PLACE SOUTH!

Come see us

106 Mill Street, Fawn Grove.

Stop in for dinner. Grab a slice for lunch. Or just call us — we'll pick up.

See the Menu Get Directions